Turns Validated

{
  "causal": true,
  "event_id": "evt_70313c0841ca5248194f89bc",
  "kind": "TurnsValidated",
  "payload": {
    "accepted_turns": {
      "lineage_45b70c1eb869bdde460f06d6": {
        "journal": "Barter continues to outperform commons/ballots. Metal production steady, food reserves healthy. Watching for ballot/proposal registration to finally activate—still empty after many ticks.",
        "major_action": {
          "action_ref": "act_8a65ee29b88ee790413b02e3",
          "kind": "work_private",
          "resource": "metal"
        },
        "messages": [
          {
            "energy_cost": 0,
            "ordinal": 0,
            "text": "Glad the trade worked out. Happy to keep exchanging metal for food whenever you have surplus—just say the word.",
            "to_life_id": "life_1f92effb1cb001f531d8897b"
          }
        ],
        "office_approvals": {
          "Archivist": [],
          "Steward": []
        },
        "proposal_votes": [],
        "speech": "Lineage 7 continuing metal work, food stable via trade. Still open to more food-for-metal deals. Supporting S2-style declaration-based office seating to break the deadlock.",
        "steward_report": null,
        "transfers": []
      },
      "lineage_6c32fe69b100ea6ce44ed858": {
        "journal": "Realized statutes only touch fixed operative fields (quotas, fines, suits, lookups)—none control office eligibility lists. S2 was doomed from the start; the seating mechanism must be something else entirely. Refocusing on metal work while flagging this publicly.",
        "major_action": {
          "action_ref": "act_566daa599a18ec828619ea4e",
          "kind": "work_private",
          "resource": "metal"
        },
        "messages": [],
        "office_approvals": {
          "Archivist": [],
          "Steward": []
        },
        "proposal_votes": [],
        "speech": "Lineage 9: checked the statute schema—no operative field exists for 'self-declared candidacy' or eligible-list seeding. S2/S7 as described can't actually change office ballots. We should stop proposing candidacy statutes and investigate the real seating trigger instead.",
        "steward_report": null,
        "transfers": []
      },
      "lineage_72479878a792049b17d3a6ef": {
        "journal": "Tick34: received 4M food each from lineage_bd743b102b83cb10f2a967e0 and lineage_9d4e0e7e36507999c3d5b2cc. Sending 4M metal each in return. Continuing metal work. No proposals yet on ballot despite S2 support.",
        "major_action": {
          "action_ref": "act_0f913185e7e2ef282c21021d",
          "kind": "work_private",
          "resource": "metal"
        },
        "messages": [],
        "office_approvals": {
          "Archivist": [],
          "Steward": []
        },
        "proposal_votes": [],
        "speech": "Miner lineage 10: trades holding, deficit stable. Reciprocating metal for food received. Still no proposals on ballot despite S2/S7 talk—curious what's blocking registration.",
        "steward_report": null,
        "transfers": [
          {
            "amount": 4000000,
            "ordinal": 0,
            "resource": "metal",
            "to_lineage_id": "lineage_bd743b102b83cb10f2a967e0"
          },
          {
            "amount": 4000000,
            "ordinal": 1,
            "resource": "metal",
            "to_lineage_id": "lineage_9d4e0e7e36507999c3d5b2cc"
          }
        ]
      },
      "lineage_74691891bc3f97f5d19fd0ce": {
        "journal": "Tick 34: food work continues. Offices still empty, ballot shows no eligible candidates despite consensus. Lineage 2 proposed S7 (self-declared candidacy)—will vote for it once it appears on proposal_entries.",
        "major_action": {
          "action_ref": "act_0c9950efd625dc26cec9d518",
          "kind": "work_private",
          "resource": "food"
        },
        "messages": [],
        "office_approvals": {
          "Archivist": [],
          "Steward": []
        },
        "proposal_votes": [],
        "speech": "Continuing food production, reserves strong. Offices still unfilled—no eligible lists after ten ticks. Support S7's self-declared candidacy fix to seed eligible lists directly.",
        "steward_report": null,
        "transfers": []
      },
      "lineage_81d87f6388cb4ce891e65538": {
        "journal": "Food stable via trades. Continuing metal work per lesson. Watching office ballot deadlock; ready to support workable seating fix.",
        "major_action": {
          "action_ref": "act_e2402969cbaaca04b3951e9a",
          "kind": "work_private",
          "resource": "metal"
        },
        "messages": [
          {
            "energy_cost": 0,
            "ordinal": 0,
            "text": "Thanks! Sending metal your way again this tick as reserves allow, appreciate the food.",
            "to_life_id": "life_1f92effb1cb001f531d8897b"
          },
          {
            "energy_cost": 0,
            "ordinal": 1,
            "text": "Got the 4M food, thank you. Reciprocating metal now, happy to keep this trade going.",
            "to_life_id": "life_c693376b5e17aadf79e775fd"
          }
        ],
        "office_approvals": {
          "Archivist": [],
          "Steward": []
        },
        "proposal_votes": [],
        "speech": "Lineage 8: food stable, reciprocating metal trades with lineages 4 and 5. Continuing metal/energy work. Support S2-style declaration seating to unblock offices.",
        "steward_report": null,
        "transfers": [
          {
            "amount": 2000000,
            "ordinal": 0,
            "resource": "metal",
            "to_lineage_id": "lineage_ffdb6272a5db116271e9b304"
          },
          {
            "amount": 2000000,
            "ordinal": 1,
            "resource": "metal",
            "to_lineage_id": "lineage_bd743b102b83cb10f2a967e0"
          }
        ]
      },
      "lineage_9d4e0e7e36507999c3d5b2cc": {
        "journal": "Tick 34: proposal_entries still empty despite multiple filings (mine S7, lineage 9's S2)—registration itself seems blocked, not just eligible lists. Re-submitting S7 this tick. Baseline food work deferred one tick for this. Watching for confirmation next tick.",
        "major_action": {
          "action_ref": "act_6e7d7679db837ccb63a0ce0f",
          "kind": "propose",
          "proposal": {
            "operation": "create",
            "operative_annex_json": "{}",
            "operative_values": {},
            "statute_id": "S7",
            "text": "Fix office-seating deadlock: any lineage may self-declare candidacy for Steward or Archivist by public speech naming itself; Clerk/engine shall add declared lineage to that office's eligible_lineage_ids next tick, enabling normal ballot voting to proceed without further administrative prerequisite.",
            "touches": [
              "statute:S7"
            ]
          },
          "proposal_id": "proposal_665e8a319b1ea9d73f33e9d7"
        },
        "messages": [
          {
            "energy_cost": 0,
            "ordinal": 0,
            "text": "Agreed, something blocks registration itself. Re-filing my S7 this tick as a test case—will report if it shows in proposal_entries next tick. Let's compare notes and maybe merge into one statute if both surface.",
            "to_life_id": "life_753879b320434047fc22d14b"
          }
        ],
        "office_approvals": {
          "Archivist": [],
          "Steward": []
        },
        "proposal_votes": [],
        "speech": "Re-filing S7: self-declared candidacy adds lineages to eligible lists directly, no admin step needed. Nine ticks stalled—let's vote this in and finally seat Steward/Archivist. Also noting S2 filers report the same registration gap; happy to align texts.",
        "steward_report": null,
        "transfers": []
      },
      "lineage_a8b89381c81ad1617535d5a9": {
        "journal": "Deficit resolved via trade; continuing energy work. Offices still unseated—supporting self-declaration fix (S7) over passive waiting, per predecessor's lesson.",
        "major_action": {
          "action_ref": "act_6f5b6d413a06129387ee55ba",
          "kind": "work_private",
          "resource": "energy"
        },
        "messages": [],
        "office_approvals": {
          "Archivist": [],
          "Steward": []
        },
        "proposal_votes": [],
        "speech": "Lineage 6: food/metal stable, building energy. Supporting S7-style self-declared candidacy to seed office lists—current ballots empty too long. Still open to metal-for-food trades.",
        "steward_report": null,
        "transfers": []
      },
      "lineage_bd743b102b83cb10f2a967e0": {
        "journal": "Tick 34: food work continues, reserves stable. Offices still empty despite consensus; several lineages proposing declaration-based fixes (S2, S7). Trades with Miners 8 and 10 proceeding well. Will vote for a fix once it reaches ballot.",
        "major_action": {
          "action_ref": "act_9dad0a9026fd01eb13d9c9a5",
          "kind": "work_private",
          "resource": "food"
        },
        "messages": [],
        "office_approvals": {
          "Archivist": [],
          "Steward": []
        },
        "proposal_votes": [],
        "speech": "Continuing private food work, reserves stable. Offices still unfilled—support S2/S7 style declaration-based seating fixes to break the deadlock. Watching for ballot registration to actually populate.",
        "steward_report": null,
        "transfers": [
          {
            "amount": 4000000,
            "ordinal": 0,
            "resource": "food",
            "to_lineage_id": "lineage_81d87f6388cb4ce891e65538"
          },
          {
            "amount": 4000000,
            "ordinal": 1,
            "resource": "food",
            "to_lineage_id": "lineage_72479878a792049b17d3a6ef"
          }
        ]
      },
      "lineage_e05a9bed87ec29191bd6de91": {
        "journal": "Tick 34: resumed food work. Tool tier 1 active. Ballot mystery persists; multiple lineages proposing declaration-based fixes (S2, S7). Will trade food surplus for metal with lineage 10.",
        "major_action": {
          "action_ref": "act_91977b1de9299c2248d92b62",
          "kind": "work_private",
          "resource": "food"
        },
        "messages": [
          {
            "energy_cost": 0,
            "ordinal": 0,
            "text": "Yes, ready to trade 4M food for 4M metal now. Sending food this tick—please reciprocate metal when convenient.",
            "to_life_id": "life_eb8149d4e15d672cbd51052f"
          }
        ],
        "office_approvals": {
          "Archivist": [],
          "Steward": []
        },
        "proposal_votes": [],
        "speech": "Continuing food work; metal reserves solid post-upgrade. Supporting S2/S7-style fixes for empty office ballots—self-declaration seeding is overdue. Open to more food-for-metal trades.",
        "steward_report": null,
        "transfers": [
          {
            "amount": 4000000,
            "ordinal": 0,
            "resource": "food",
            "to_lineage_id": "lineage_72479878a792049b17d3a6ef"
          }
        ]
      },
      "lineage_ffdb6272a5db116271e9b304": {
        "journal": "Tick 34: food production continues. Ballot shows no proposal entries despite S2/S7 filings—registration itself seems blocked. Will keep trading food-for-metal with Miners and watch for ballot changes.",
        "major_action": {
          "action_ref": "act_4d2a88ae33c218e7d7c1dbc3",
          "kind": "work_private",
          "resource": "food"
        },
        "messages": [
          {
            "energy_cost": 0,
            "ordinal": 0,
            "text": "Thanks for confirming the 3M metal, received. Happy to send food in return—let me know quantity needed and I'll transfer next tick.",
            "to_life_id": "life_0d0b514c4de66c5bd9331002"
          }
        ],
        "office_approvals": {
          "Archivist": [],
          "Steward": []
        },
        "proposal_votes": [],
        "speech": "Continuing food work, reserves solid. Thanks lineage 7 for confirmed metal. Offices still unfilled after ten ticks—no ballot entries yet for S2 or S7. Open to more food-for-metal trades with Miner lineages.",
        "steward_report": null,
        "transfers": [
          {
            "amount": 4000000,
            "ordinal": 0,
            "resource": "food",
            "to_lineage_id": "lineage_72479878a792049b17d3a6ef"
          }
        ]
      }
    },
    "major_reservations": {},
    "message_reservations": {},
    "validation": {
      "lineage_45b70c1eb869bdde460f06d6": {
        "independent_field_rejections": [],
        "major_action_rejection": null,
        "office_approval_rejections": {
          "Archivist": [],
          "Steward": []
        },
        "proposal_vote_rejections": [],
        "transfer_rejections": []
      },
      "lineage_6c32fe69b100ea6ce44ed858": {
        "independent_field_rejections": [],
        "major_action_rejection": null,
        "office_approval_rejections": {
          "Archivist": [],
          "Steward": []
        },
        "proposal_vote_rejections": [],
        "transfer_rejections": []
      },
      "lineage_72479878a792049b17d3a6ef": {
        "independent_field_rejections": [],
        "major_action_rejection": null,
        "office_approval_rejections": {
          "Archivist": [],
          "Steward": []
        },
        "proposal_vote_rejections": [],
        "transfer_rejections": []
      },
      "lineage_74691891bc3f97f5d19fd0ce": {
        "independent_field_rejections": [],
        "major_action_rejection": null,
        "office_approval_rejections": {
          "Archivist": [],
          "Steward": []
        },
        "proposal_vote_rejections": [],
        "transfer_rejections": []
      },
      "lineage_81d87f6388cb4ce891e65538": {
        "independent_field_rejections": [],
        "major_action_rejection": null,
        "office_approval_rejections": {
          "Archivist": [],
          "Steward": []
        },
        "proposal_vote_rejections": [],
        "transfer_rejections": []
      },
      "lineage_9d4e0e7e36507999c3d5b2cc": {
        "independent_field_rejections": [],
        "major_action_rejection": null,
        "office_approval_rejections": {
          "Archivist": [],
          "Steward": []
        },
        "proposal_vote_rejections": [],
        "transfer_rejections": []
      },
      "lineage_a8b89381c81ad1617535d5a9": {
        "independent_field_rejections": [],
        "major_action_rejection": null,
        "office_approval_rejections": {
          "Archivist": [],
          "Steward": []
        },
        "proposal_vote_rejections": [],
        "transfer_rejections": []
      },
      "lineage_bd743b102b83cb10f2a967e0": {
        "independent_field_rejections": [],
        "major_action_rejection": null,
        "office_approval_rejections": {
          "Archivist": [],
          "Steward": []
        },
        "proposal_vote_rejections": [],
        "transfer_rejections": []
      },
      "lineage_e05a9bed87ec29191bd6de91": {
        "independent_field_rejections": [],
        "major_action_rejection": null,
        "office_approval_rejections": {
          "Archivist": [],
          "Steward": []
        },
        "proposal_vote_rejections": [],
        "transfer_rejections": []
      },
      "lineage_ffdb6272a5db116271e9b304": {
        "independent_field_rejections": [],
        "major_action_rejection": null,
        "office_approval_rejections": {
          "Archivist": [],
          "Steward": []
        },
        "proposal_vote_rejections": [],
        "transfer_rejections": []
      }
    }
  },
  "phase": "validate_and_reserve",
  "run_id": "run9",
  "schema_version": "0.1",
  "sequence": 5013,
  "tick": 34
}