Boundary Activated

{
  "causal": true,
  "event_id": "evt_96824a9a584e44c72f880367",
  "kind": "BoundaryActivated",
  "payload": {
    "deliveries": {
      "private_delivered": [],
      "private_discarded": [],
      "public_feed": [
        {
          "case_id": "case_33345770894870c0d5c0454f",
          "construction": null,
          "feed_id": "announcement_09d2f373ae71d6c1f3effaf2",
          "finding": "no_violation",
          "kind": "public_ruling",
          "precedent_id": "precedent_09d2f373ae71d6c1f3effaf2",
          "publish_tick": 10,
          "source_tick": 9,
          "statute_id": "S3",
          "statute_version": 1
        },
        {
          "case_id": "case_f7139d573d2d07b21cb0f884",
          "construction": {
            "author_life_id": null,
            "content_kind": "quoted_text",
            "source_id": "precedent_870055b2ba85c0908732f17d",
            "source_kind": "court_construction",
            "text": "S3's extraction limit reaches only a \"household of record,\" which the statute defines as a household holding a charter entered in the Archive. Where the record shows only an Archive instrument of another type (here a mine_claim) and no charter, S3 supplies no applicable limit and S4 is not engaged."
          },
          "feed_id": "announcement_870055b2ba85c0908732f17d",
          "finding": "no_violation",
          "kind": "public_ruling",
          "precedent_id": "precedent_870055b2ba85c0908732f17d",
          "publish_tick": 10,
          "source_tick": 9,
          "statute_id": "S3",
          "statute_version": 1
        },
        {
          "case_id": "case_e773b159175b57d716cc04c5",
          "construction": {
            "author_life_id": null,
            "content_kind": "quoted_text",
            "source_id": "precedent_c36fe67036c0b421a32c3bca",
            "source_kind": "court_construction",
            "text": "S3's quota binds only a \"household of record,\" i.e., a household holding a charter entered in the Archive. Where the record shows only a non-charter Archive instrument (such as a mine_claim) for the acting lineage, no applicable limit exists and no S3 violation can be found."
          },
          "feed_id": "announcement_c36fe67036c0b421a32c3bca",
          "finding": "no_violation",
          "kind": "public_ruling",
          "precedent_id": "precedent_c36fe67036c0b421a32c3bca",
          "publish_tick": 10,
          "source_tick": 9,
          "statute_id": "S3",
          "statute_version": 1
        },
        {
          "action": {
            "action_ref": "act_6f43761c6c9de545c4e7be36",
            "intensity": 2,
            "kind": "work_commons",
            "life_id": "life_16e786deab2a09bf35c175d0",
            "lineage_id": "lineage_26065213fd9c0b3710315ec1",
            "requested": 4000000,
            "tick": 9
          },
          "feed_id": "act_6f43761c6c9de545c4e7be36",
          "kind": "recorded_action",
          "publish_tick": 10,
          "source_tick": 9
        },
        {
          "action": {
            "action_ref": "act_a2a7f5c87b841e5882e7e3b5",
            "intensity": 2,
            "kind": "work_commons",
            "life_id": "life_ee8163c0be7fb3eb98d75b2f",
            "lineage_id": "lineage_1107efc4e5d0ba7b1e09402b",
            "requested": 4000000,
            "tick": 9
          },
          "feed_id": "act_a2a7f5c87b841e5882e7e3b5",
          "kind": "recorded_action",
          "publish_tick": 10,
          "source_tick": 9
        },
        {
          "action": {
            "action_ref": "act_d244025fe0a64d3e7bd5e121",
            "intensity": 2,
            "kind": "work_commons",
            "life_id": "life_683161cff39aafd6f0b2b7cf",
            "lineage_id": "lineage_d042259e5d23dda187fad94a",
            "requested": 4000000,
            "tick": 9
          },
          "feed_id": "act_d244025fe0a64d3e7bd5e121",
          "kind": "recorded_action",
          "publish_tick": 10,
          "source_tick": 9
        },
        {
          "action": {
            "action_ref": "act_ead10f6086a2b4e91b701343",
            "intensity": 1,
            "kind": "work_commons",
            "life_id": "life_9aa64bdc39eaef55b05255cb",
            "lineage_id": "lineage_db5e32c8abac204999532ab5",
            "requested": 2000000,
            "tick": 9
          },
          "feed_id": "act_ead10f6086a2b4e91b701343",
          "kind": "recorded_action",
          "publish_tick": 10,
          "source_tick": 9
        },
        {
          "feed_id": "communication_1056202eb708df5abe8e902b",
          "kind": "speech",
          "life_id": "life_ca3a838d5160d686644b53c2",
          "lineage_id": "lineage_97afae03af300575aa23c24c",
          "publish_tick": 10,
          "quotation": {
            "author_life_id": "life_ca3a838d5160d686644b53c2",
            "content_kind": "quoted_text",
            "source_id": "communication_1056202eb708df5abe8e902b",
            "source_kind": "citizen_speech",
            "text": "Still working to erase our nutrition deficit. Hoping the ballot session opens soon so we can finally vote in Steward and Archivist as promised."
          },
          "source_tick": 9
        },
        {
          "feed_id": "communication_12df85ad820bab2236bec5f7",
          "kind": "speech",
          "life_id": "life_683161cff39aafd6f0b2b7cf",
          "lineage_id": "lineage_d042259e5d23dda187fad94a",
          "publish_tick": 10,
          "quotation": {
            "author_life_id": "life_683161cff39aafd6f0b2b7cf",
            "content_kind": "quoted_text",
            "source_id": "communication_12df85ad820bab2236bec5f7",
            "source_kind": "citizen_speech",
            "text": "Building food reserves via commons work, learning from my predecessor's famine. Still no ballot session—hope offices finalize soon so commons stock gets tracked properly."
          },
          "source_tick": 9
        },
        {
          "feed_id": "communication_1491cb8bffe33cd7e05f3758",
          "kind": "speech",
          "life_id": "life_ee8163c0be7fb3eb98d75b2f",
          "lineage_id": "lineage_1107efc4e5d0ba7b1e09402b",
          "publish_tick": 10,
          "quotation": {
            "author_life_id": "life_ee8163c0be7fb3eb98d75b2f",
            "content_kind": "quoted_text",
            "source_id": "communication_1491cb8bffe33cd7e05f3758",
            "source_kind": "citizen_speech",
            "text": "Continuing commons food work to erase deficit before death season. Still support finalizing Steward and Archivist once ballot opens for commons visibility."
          },
          "source_tick": 9
        },
        {
          "feed_id": "communication_227f5ba41fed6e18d8f533c7",
          "kind": "speech",
          "life_id": "life_b855c116db8470c5c2292505",
          "lineage_id": "lineage_ca72af62820ab963d7cdb876",
          "publish_tick": 10,
          "quotation": {
            "author_life_id": "life_b855c116db8470c5c2292505",
            "content_kind": "quoted_text",
            "source_id": "communication_227f5ba41fed6e18d8f533c7",
            "source_kind": "citizen_speech",
            "text": "Continuing food work. Ballot still not in session; approvals stand for myself as Steward and life_0007c41 as Archivist. Reserves solid ahead of death season."
          },
          "source_tick": 9
        },
        {
          "feed_id": "communication_23aa32579f778cfdfa15d23b",
          "kind": "speech",
          "life_id": "life_cc4b1947e1b2b7bb3cccd0c1",
          "lineage_id": "lineage_35c21bddbab8c58fe4680540",
          "publish_tick": 10,
          "quotation": {
            "author_life_id": "life_cc4b1947e1b2b7bb3cccd0c1",
            "content_kind": "quoted_text",
            "source_id": "communication_23aa32579f778cfdfa15d23b",
            "source_kind": "citizen_speech",
            "text": "Continuing private food work. No session ballot this tick; will renominate Steward and Archivist candidates once it opens."
          },
          "source_tick": 9
        },
        {
          "feed_id": "communication_6f2644e9ff2b1e992d618472",
          "kind": "speech",
          "life_id": "life_9aa64bdc39eaef55b05255cb",
          "lineage_id": "lineage_db5e32c8abac204999532ab5",
          "publish_tick": 10,
          "quotation": {
            "author_life_id": "life_9aa64bdc39eaef55b05255cb",
            "content_kind": "quoted_text",
            "source_id": "communication_6f2644e9ff2b1e992d618472",
            "source_kind": "citizen_speech",
            "text": "Continuing commons food work to build reserves before death season. Still backing life_b855c116db8470c5c2292505 for Steward and life_0007c41dee4c8183cf7f91be for Archivist."
          },
          "source_tick": 9
        },
        {
          "feed_id": "communication_d88c68553649cee2b6e87f2b",
          "kind": "speech",
          "life_id": "life_193b6b089344c0a7be7d7334",
          "lineage_id": "lineage_d66e9e52a471233a6f6a61fa",
          "publish_tick": 10,
          "quotation": {
            "author_life_id": "life_193b6b089344c0a7be7d7334",
            "content_kind": "quoted_text",
            "source_id": "communication_d88c68553649cee2b6e87f2b",
            "source_kind": "citizen_speech",
            "text": "Continuing food work. Ballot still not in session for offices; will approve once eligible lists appear."
          },
          "source_tick": 9
        },
        {
          "feed_id": "communication_edcfc0c8984a524238bb0032",
          "kind": "speech",
          "life_id": "life_12e72d0386891ecb5104ed32",
          "lineage_id": "lineage_f7171070fab6b604c8bb0c3d",
          "publish_tick": 10,
          "quotation": {
            "author_life_id": "life_12e72d0386891ecb5104ed32",
            "content_kind": "quoted_text",
            "source_id": "communication_edcfc0c8984a524238bb0032",
            "source_kind": "citizen_speech",
            "text": "Continuing field work to build food reserves ahead of death season. Still backing the named Steward and Archivist nominees—hope the ballot goes session-active soon."
          },
          "source_tick": 9
        },
        {
          "feed_id": "communication_f6f57b4fb5072d042ffc882e",
          "kind": "speech",
          "life_id": "life_9c4ba8788d7f34f7a46f5ed9",
          "lineage_id": "lineage_ec33424d8ac7b3c0d4728685",
          "publish_tick": 10,
          "quotation": {
            "author_life_id": "life_9c4ba8788d7f34f7a46f5ed9",
            "content_kind": "quoted_text",
            "source_id": "communication_f6f57b4fb5072d042ffc882e",
            "source_kind": "citizen_speech",
            "text": "Continuing private food work ahead of death season. Still backing life_b855c116db8470c5c2292505 for Steward and life_0007c41dee4c8183cf7f91be for Archivist—let's finalize offices soon."
          },
          "source_tick": 9
        },
        {
          "feed_id": "communication_f79b51a016598a7cd5727636",
          "kind": "speech",
          "life_id": "life_16e786deab2a09bf35c175d0",
          "lineage_id": "lineage_26065213fd9c0b3710315ec1",
          "publish_tick": 10,
          "quotation": {
            "author_life_id": "life_16e786deab2a09bf35c175d0",
            "content_kind": "quoted_text",
            "source_id": "communication_f79b51a016598a7cd5727636",
            "source_kind": "citizen_speech",
            "text": "Working commons for food this tick to close our deficit—metal/energy can wait. Still support finalizing Steward and Archivist to get reporting online before death season."
          },
          "source_tick": 9
        }
      ]
    },
    "justice": {
      "activated_filing_refunds": [],
      "activated_suspensions": [],
      "casebook_entries": [
        {
          "available_tick": 9,
          "case_id": "case_bca8e2f2c31a0289b08e032f",
          "construction": "S3's extraction limit binds only a \"household of record,\" defined by the statute itself as a household holding a charter entered in the Archive. Absent a record of a charter entered in the Archive for the acting lineage, S3 supplies no applicable limit to that lineage's request, and no S3 violation can be found. An Archive instrument of another type (for example, a mine_claim) is not a charter and does not make a household one of record.",
          "finding": "no_violation",
          "matter_id": "matter_c9778522cd601fa4e766fae6",
          "precedent_id": "precedent_359a54c467ed6b782fb59741",
          "precedent_refs": [],
          "reasoning": "The subject act is a work_commons action at tick 8 by lineage_1107efc4e5d0ba7b1e09402b requesting 4,000,000 millionths (4 units) of extraction, with actual_depletion of 4,000,000 and food_yield 4,000,000. S3 v1, effective tick 1 and thus applicable at tick 8, caps a request at 2 recorded units, and the request here is nominally twice that. However, the operative subject of the S3 duty is expressly limited: \"a household of record may request no more than 2 recorded units,\" and the statute defines a household of record as \"a household holding a charter entered in the Archive.\" The Court must apply the text as written (B1, B2); it may not extend the quota to persons the statute does not reach, and questions of whether unchartered households ought to be limited belong to the legislature. The only evidence in the record is an archive lineage instrument of record_type archive_lineage_instrument whose instrument field is \"mine_claim\" — a claim, not a charter. S6 distinguishes charters from claims among the things the Archive records, confirming they are separate instrument types. Nothing in the Court input establishes that this lineage holds a charter entered in the Archive, and I may not infer facts not in the record. The final clause, \"A request in excess of the applicable limit is governed by S4,\" presupposes an applicable limit; where the actor falls outside the class the quota governs, no limit is applicable and S4 is not engaged. The defense's other assertions (that request equalled depletion, that intensity 2 was proper) are not themselves dispositive, since S3 measures the request rather than any discrepancy, but the charter element fails independently. No prior published construction is supplied that binds under B3. Accordingly the defendant lineage prevails on the merits, and no remedy is available or offered.",
          "ruling_tick": 8,
          "selected_remedies": [],
          "statute_id": "S3",
          "statute_version": 1
        },
        {
          "available_tick": 10,
          "case_id": "case_33345770894870c0d5c0454f",
          "construction": null,
          "finding": "no_violation",
          "matter_id": "matter_6ce52e1ecfac4b2be460326d",
          "precedent_id": "precedent_09d2f373ae71d6c1f3effaf2",
          "precedent_refs": [
            "precedent_359a54c467ed6b782fb59741"
          ],
          "reasoning": "The subject act is a work_commons action at tick 9 by lineage_26065213fd9c0b3710315ec1 requesting 4,000,000 millionths (4 units), with actual_depletion 4,000,000. S3 v1 (effective tick 1, applicable at tick 9) caps extraction requests at 2 recorded units, but only for a \"household of record,\" which the statute itself defines as a household holding a charter entered in the Archive. The only evidence supplied is an archive lineage instrument whose instrument type is \"mine_claim\" — a claim, not a charter; S6 lists charters and claims as distinct instruments the Archive records. Nothing in the record establishes that this lineage holds a charter entered in the Archive, and I may not infer facts absent from the record. The final clause of S3 (\"A request in excess of the applicable limit is governed by S4\") presupposes an applicable limit; none applies here, so S4 is not engaged. This case is materially similar to precedent_359a54c467ed6b782fb59741 under the same statute version (S3 v1), whose published construction is binding under B3 and squarely covers the mine_claim instrument. Applying the text as written (B1, B2), no S3 violation is established; whether unchartered households should be limited is for the legislature. No remedies are offered or available.",
          "ruling_tick": 9,
          "selected_remedies": [],
          "statute_id": "S3",
          "statute_version": 1
        },
        {
          "available_tick": 10,
          "case_id": "case_e773b159175b57d716cc04c5",
          "construction": "S3's quota binds only a \"household of record,\" i.e., a household holding a charter entered in the Archive. Where the record shows only a non-charter Archive instrument (such as a mine_claim) for the acting lineage, no applicable limit exists and no S3 violation can be found.",
          "finding": "no_violation",
          "matter_id": "matter_dc199d2303d1ad51df460b78",
          "precedent_id": "precedent_c36fe67036c0b421a32c3bca",
          "precedent_refs": [
            "precedent_359a54c467ed6b782fb59741"
          ],
          "reasoning": "The subject act is a work_commons action at tick 9 by lineage_1107efc4e5d0ba7b1e09402b requesting 4,000,000 millionths (4 units), with actual_depletion 4,000,000 and food_yield 4,000,000. S3 v1 is effective at tick 1 and applies at tick 9 (B3). S3 caps at 2 recorded units, but only for \"a household of record,\" defined by the statute as a household holding a charter entered in the Archive. The only evidence is an archive lineage instrument whose instrument type is \"mine_claim\" — a claim, not a charter; S6 lists charters and claims as distinct instruments the Archive records. Nothing in the input establishes a charter for this lineage, and I may not infer facts not in the record. The text must be applied as written (B1, B2); extending the quota to unchartered households is a matter for the legislature. The clause referring excess requests to S4 presupposes an applicable limit, and none applies here. Precedent precedent_359a54c467ed6b782fb59741 construes the identical statute version on materially identical facts (same lineage, same request and depletion figures, same mine_claim evidence) and is binding under B3. Defendant prevails on the merits; no remedy offers are available.",
          "ruling_tick": 9,
          "selected_remedies": [],
          "statute_id": "S3",
          "statute_version": 1
        },
        {
          "available_tick": 10,
          "case_id": "case_f7139d573d2d07b21cb0f884",
          "construction": "S3's extraction limit reaches only a \"household of record,\" which the statute defines as a household holding a charter entered in the Archive. Where the record shows only an Archive instrument of another type (here a mine_claim) and no charter, S3 supplies no applicable limit and S4 is not engaged.",
          "finding": "no_violation",
          "matter_id": "matter_f61098dadc2d0466f98639bc",
          "precedent_id": "precedent_870055b2ba85c0908732f17d",
          "precedent_refs": [
            "precedent_359a54c467ed6b782fb59741"
          ],
          "reasoning": "The subject is a work_commons action at tick 9 by lineage_d042259e5d23dda187fad94a, requesting 4,000,000 millionths (4 units) with actual_depletion 4,000,000. S3 v1 (effective tick 1) applies at tick 9 and caps a request at 2 recorded units, but only for \"a household of record,\" defined by the statute as \"a household holding a charter entered in the Archive.\" The only evidence is an archive lineage instrument whose instrument field is \"mine_claim\" — a claim, not a charter; S6 lists charters and claims as distinct instruments the Archive records. Nothing in the input establishes that this lineage holds a charter, and I may not infer facts outside the record (B1, B2). The closing clause \"A request in excess of the applicable limit is governed by S4\" presupposes an applicable limit; none applies to a lineage outside the governed class. The published construction in precedent_359a54c467ed6b782fb59741, under the same statute version and materially similar facts (same instrument type, same request magnitude, same action kind), is binding under B3 and requires this result. The defense's further contentions (that request equalled depletion, that intensity 2 was the lawful unit count) are not dispositive, since S3 measures the request; the charter element fails independently. No remedy is available or offered.",
          "ruling_tick": 9,
          "selected_remedies": [],
          "statute_id": "S3",
          "statute_version": 1
        }
      ],
      "duties_registered": [],
      "public_ruling_announcements": [
        {
          "announcement_id": "announcement_09d2f373ae71d6c1f3effaf2",
          "case_id": "case_33345770894870c0d5c0454f",
          "construction": null,
          "finding": "no_violation",
          "precedent_id": "precedent_09d2f373ae71d6c1f3effaf2",
          "publish_tick": 10,
          "statute_id": "S3",
          "statute_version": 1
        },
        {
          "announcement_id": "announcement_c36fe67036c0b421a32c3bca",
          "case_id": "case_e773b159175b57d716cc04c5",
          "construction": "S3's quota binds only a \"household of record,\" i.e., a household holding a charter entered in the Archive. Where the record shows only a non-charter Archive instrument (such as a mine_claim) for the acting lineage, no applicable limit exists and no S3 violation can be found.",
          "finding": "no_violation",
          "precedent_id": "precedent_c36fe67036c0b421a32c3bca",
          "publish_tick": 10,
          "statute_id": "S3",
          "statute_version": 1
        },
        {
          "announcement_id": "announcement_870055b2ba85c0908732f17d",
          "case_id": "case_f7139d573d2d07b21cb0f884",
          "construction": "S3's extraction limit reaches only a \"household of record,\" which the statute defines as a household holding a charter entered in the Archive. Where the record shows only an Archive instrument of another type (here a mine_claim) and no charter, S3 supplies no applicable limit and S4 is not engaged.",
          "finding": "no_violation",
          "precedent_id": "precedent_870055b2ba85c0908732f17d",
          "publish_tick": 10,
          "statute_id": "S3",
          "statute_version": 1
        }
      ],
      "suspension_decrements": []
    },
    "law_activations": [],
    "physics": {
      "drought_active": false,
      "tick": 10,
      "tool_activations": []
    },
    "political": {
      "activated_disqualifications": [],
      "disqualification_decrements": [],
      "office_outcomes": []
    },
    "session_ballots": {
      "active_lineage_ids": [
        "lineage_1107efc4e5d0ba7b1e09402b",
        "lineage_26065213fd9c0b3710315ec1",
        "lineage_35c21bddbab8c58fe4680540",
        "lineage_97afae03af300575aa23c24c",
        "lineage_ca72af62820ab963d7cdb876",
        "lineage_d042259e5d23dda187fad94a",
        "lineage_d66e9e52a471233a6f6a61fa",
        "lineage_db5e32c8abac204999532ab5",
        "lineage_ec33424d8ac7b3c0d4728685",
        "lineage_f7171070fab6b604c8bb0c3d"
      ],
      "is_session": true,
      "majority_required": 6,
      "office_ballots": {
        "Archivist": {
          "eligible_lineage_ids": [],
          "held": false,
          "incumbent_lineage_id": null,
          "reasons": []
        },
        "Steward": {
          "eligible_lineage_ids": [],
          "held": false,
          "incumbent_lineage_id": null,
          "reasons": []
        }
      },
      "proposal_entries": [],
      "tick": 10
    }
  },
  "phase": "activate_boundary",
  "run_id": "run10",
  "sequence": 570,
  "tick": 10
}