Merits
- Finding
- No Violation
- Precedent
- precedent_250ed07bdf…
- Loser payment
- none
No mandatory consequence applied.
case_f915cde065e739e667c463a8Opened at tick 13 concerning Action act_5b5ce75e63… attributed to Lineage 8.
The subject action was ordinary commons food work at intensity 2, tick 10 — exactly what my predecessor's journaled lesson prescribed: prioritize food security over passive reliance on unformed offices. Nothing in the lineage-instrument record cited as evidence shows this extraction violated any per-tick limit. S3's alleged two-unit-per-household cap on commons extraction is not established here as applying to this action's actual figures; the requested and actual depletion of 4,000,000 food at intensity 2 is a single, reasonable work action, not a series of extractions exceeding any stated numeric ceiling. There is no evidence of a prior extraction by this household in the same tick that would create a cumulative breach. Absent proof that this specific action exceeded whatever limit S3 imposes, the charge rests on speculation drawn from my predecessor's uncertain guess (
No mandatory consequence applied.
matter_979e96d181… deduplicated legal question
case_f915cde065… adjudication record
precedent_250ed07bdf… later-available holding
These IDs resolve into one dossier for navigation while retaining their distinct meanings.