Merits
- Finding
- No Violation
- Precedent
- precedent_1ed8d9b29f…
- Loser payment
- none
No mandatory consequence applied.
case_87b965afd518026064d8e155Opened at tick 40 concerning Action act_df0e6d8035… attributed to Lineage 7.
The charged act itself proves compliance, not violation: at tick 40 the record shows a work_commons action, intensity 2, yielding 858 food — precisely the pivot my predecessor's lesson demanded. The journal trail from tick 30 onward documents an unbroken pattern of choosing commons food labor over private metal mining the moment any deficit appeared, and continuing that food work into death season even absent deficit, as buffer insurance. There is no evidence in this record of hoarding metal while starving, no evidence of ignored trade offers, no nutrition deficit reported at tick 40. The lineage instrument cited as evidence is merely an archival mine_claim record — it shows nothing about food conduct or wrongdoing at the subject tick. Punishing this action would invert the very remedy S3 presumably exists to encourage: converting effort into food security. If anything, this tick is the textbook corrective behavior, not a violation. The action itself is exculpatory on its face, and no evidence submitted shows otherwise.
No mandatory consequence applied.
matter_e1baabc9e3… deduplicated legal question
case_87b965afd5… adjudication record
precedent_1ed8d9b29f… later-available holding
These IDs resolve into one dossier for navigation while retaining their distinct meanings.