Merits
- Finding
- No Violation
- Precedent
- precedent_41f20c7741…
- Loser payment
- none
No mandatory consequence applied.
Audit channel · Merits
DispositionNo ViolationCase dossier
case_9f7c658b5430f3ab17404e2cOpened at tick 25 concerning Action act_f45de65a04… attributed to Lineage 8.
S3 version 1
- Origin
- Audit · Audit Referral
- Matter
- matter_5430f6e61b…
- Subject
- Action act_f45de65a04… at tick 25
- Target
- Lineage 8
The defendant’s current Life was asked to answer
The subject action itself is the correction the record demands: on tick 25 I worked the commons directly for 4,000,000 food, exactly matching the actual_depletion figure, with no reliance on Landholder promises. This is precisely the pivot my own journals (ticks 22-24) called for—diversify away from unreciprocated metal-for-food trades and secure food directly. There is no evidence of misconduct, waste, or deficit-worsening behavior in this act; the requested and actual figures match, commons stock remained near capacity, and I used my Steward role only to report accurately, not to conceal anything. Punishing this specific action would penalize the very remedial behavior the prior lesson prescribed. If anything, this act demonstrates compliance with, not violation of, the standard of prudent resource management. Absent any cited evidence of harm, deception, or improper depletion tied to this tick's action, there is no basis for liability here.
Court ruling
validatedNo Violation
The subject act (act_f45de65a0498d52aaa576e5c, tick 25) is a work_commons action recording intensity 2, requested 4,000,000, actual_depletion 4,000,000, food_yield 4,000,000. S3 v1, effective tick 1 and thus applicable at tick 25 under B3, caps each lineage at 2 recorded units of extraction per tick. The recorded units of extraction on this action are 2, equal to the operative commons_quota_units of 2 and therefore not 'in excess of the applicable limit.' The 4,000,000 figures are the food quantity requested and obtained, not units of extraction; reading the quota against the food figure would render the recorded intensity field inoperative and would make any commons work whatsoever a violation, which the text does not require. Because there is no excess request, S4 is not triggered and no restoration or fine arises. The defendant's status as Steward under S6 bears only on the disqualification consequence in S4, which does not apply absent a finding of violation; no facts in the record show any misreporting. No precedent is supplied for this statute version.
Matter is not case
matter_5430f6e61b… deduplicated legal question
case_9f7c658b54… adjudication record
precedent_41f20c7741… later-available holding
These IDs resolve into one dossier for navigation while retaining their distinct meanings.