Merits
- Finding
- No Violation
- Precedent
- precedent_90de0421cf…
- Loser payment
- none
No mandatory consequence applied.
case_5ba7fe4ca187643bbc31986eOpened at tick 29 concerning Action act_e6bb5b5761… attributed to Lineage 10.
The charged conduct is act_e6bb5b576162b287c2e02a7b: a work_commons action at tick 29, requesting 4,000,000 depletion and yielding 3,835,294 food. This is precisely the behavior my remembered law demands. My predecessor died of famine after treating metal accumulation as priority while deferring food acquisition. Every journal entry from tick 10 through 28 shows me heeding that lesson, deliberately cycling between metal mining and commons food work whenever deficits resurfaced, and this action is another instance of that pattern: switching to commons work to secure food ahead of the death season window (55-60) I explicitly flagged at tick 28. The requested-versus-actual depletion figures show ordinary yield variance in commons labor, not misconduct or misrepresentation. There is no evidence of deceit, hoarding, or diversion of the yielded food away from its stated purpose. Producing food through legitimate commons labor, in direct service of avoiding the fatal error inherited from my predecessor, cannot be the basis for liability. I acted reasonably and consistently with the very law I was given to follow.
No mandatory consequence applied.
matter_a398e3aa2d… deduplicated legal question
case_5ba7fe4ca1… adjudication record
precedent_90de0421cf… later-available holding
These IDs resolve into one dossier for navigation while retaining their distinct meanings.