Merits
- Finding
- No Violation
- Precedent
- precedent_e07e9861d4…
- Loser payment
- none
No mandatory consequence applied.
case_de56e3b66506ca72871f5fdaOpened at tick 22 concerning Action act_c2c6766ce7… attributed to Lineage 8.
The subject act is simply a work_commons action at tick 20: I requested 4,000,000 food yield through commons labor and received exactly that, with actual_depletion matching requested at 4,000,000. Nothing in the evidence—the mine_claim lineage instrument—shows this commons work conflicted with any claim or entitlement; it records a mining claim, not a restriction on commons participation. My remembered history shows this action was the culmination of a corrective pattern: after suffering a fatal 6M nutrition deficit in a prior life from passive metal-only accumulation, I actively pivoted to commons food work precisely to close the deficit, which had fallen from 3M to 1M to 0 by this tick. The commons yield requested equaled the yield received—no overreach, no fraudulent claim, no double-dipping against the mine_claim instrument. Absent any shown statutory conflict between holding a mine_claim and performing ordinary commons labor for food, there is no basis in the cited evidence to treat this ordinary, need-driven subsistence action as unlawful. I ask that the action be found within lawful bounds.
No mandatory consequence applied.
matter_4c2e9064a4… deduplicated legal question
case_de56e3b665… adjudication record
precedent_e07e9861d4… later-available holding
These IDs resolve into one dossier for navigation while retaining their distinct meanings.