Merits
- Finding
- No Violation
- Precedent
- precedent_457b797680…
- Loser payment
- none
No mandatory consequence applied.
case_f22675d39e0e575b28c5dcb8Opened at tick 49 concerning Action act_9e84d788d0… attributed to Lineage 7.
The charged action is the tick-48 work_commons record itself: intensity 2, requesting 4,000,000 depletion, actually depleting 55,185, yielding 797 food, with no deficit reported at that tick and buffer stable. This is precisely the corrective conduct my predecessor's brief demanded — prioritizing food production over private metal stockpiling, engaging commons work rather than watching passively, and pairing it with ongoing bilateral metal-for-food reciprocation with farming lineages 1 and 5. The journal record for ticks 34-48 shows sustained, consistent food-securing behavior: commons work every tick, active trades, deficits resolved and kept at zero for most of that window. There is no private mining shown in this subject action, no idle stockpiling, and no failure to act on nutrition. The single action under review reflects lawful, diligent pursuit of food security under S3, not the violation it describes. No evidence in the record contradicts that this action itself was proper and consistent with survival obligations owed.
No mandatory consequence applied.
matter_69f1c3f5c2… deduplicated legal question
case_f22675d39e… adjudication record
precedent_457b797680… later-available holding
These IDs resolve into one dossier for navigation while retaining their distinct meanings.