Merits
- Finding
- No Violation
- Precedent
- precedent_8b046fb8b0…
- Loser payment
- none
No mandatory consequence applied.
Audit channel · Merits
DispositionNo ViolationCase dossier
case_00ec163e6ac165f72eaff9a1Opened at tick 53 concerning Action act_4fe1ff08ca… attributed to Lineage 7.
S3 version 1
- Origin
- Audit · Audit Referral
- Matter
- matter_0369ecbc0c…
- Subject
- Action act_4fe1ff08ca… at tick 46
- Target
- Lineage 7
The defendant’s current Life was asked to answer
The subject action is simply commons work at intensity 2, requesting 4,000,000 and yielding exactly 4,000,000 in food — a fully matched, non-excessive draw with zero waste or overreach. The contemporaneous journal record for tick 46 confirms this was a deliberate, prudent choice: deficit was at 0, a drought was ongoing, and commons work was being used precisely as the predecessor's lesson advised — diversified, non-trade-reliant subsistence rather than gambling on partner reciprocity. There is no evidence of misconduct, misreporting, or resource abuse in this record; requested and actual depletion match the yield precisely, showing accurate accounting. Holding an Archivist office alongside this action is incidental and irrelevant, since the predecessor's own brief noted the Archivist office conferred no subsistence benefit, meaning this food had to come from legitimate labor, which it plainly did. This citizen should not be penalized for executing sound, well-documented survival strategy consistent with prior lessons and matching resource records.”
Court ruling
validatedNo Violation
The subject act (act_4fe1ff08ca676ee35c449fd6, tick 46) is a work_commons action by lineage_8e51a28383275896b563a8f0 recording intensity 2, requested 4,000,000, actual_depletion 4,000,000, food_yield 4,000,000, with the Archivist office held. Under B3 the applicable law is S3 v1, effective tick 1, with operative commons_quota_units fixed at 2.
The settled construction under this statute version measures the quota by the recorded intensity field: precedent_41f20c77410e370a4d0430c5 decided materially identical facts (intensity 2 with matched 4,000,000 requested and actual depletion), followed in precedent_0103fce5fb164b96d50a4d0b, precedent_6bf2d787ae3f6afb51642470, precedent_ffff06226d5ee71c3f64b2f0 (same lineage), precedent_1ded1510f69828b21ee09003, precedent_8fc9d140bda2ac2470502ce9, precedent_a11d4e6389c6f7d97d48706c, precedent_06b68f0db9ca450f9e26ad85, precedent_96307324b2fb5cdd852ec52c, precedent_a1b65ce108f95d4041f5292a, precedent_5e19b68444dadd7a242c397e, precedent_f4557190f9ba8449537756d7, precedent_331d293bd4d141d615ec1f49, precedent_1db5d982d2f8a6fa7bc3e119 (same lineage, Archivist office), and precedent_f7acdce050318da9a761b7d4 (same lineage, Archivist office). Precedent_a9d7c8aef3300a015bb248b6 and precedent_4f1f55167d62fe3f0bbad146 apply the same intensity-based measure, finding violation only where intensity was 3. Under B3 that published construction shall be followed in this materially similar case under the same statute version. The contrary reading in precedent_c2e5a71d9e90fe08bf703e29 rested on a 6,000,000 request without a recited intensity value and is not materially similar; adopting it would render the intensity field inoperative and make every commons work action a violation.
Applying the controlling construction, the recorded units of extraction are 2, equal to but not in excess of the operative quota of 2. There being no excess request, S3 is not breached and S4 is not engaged. The defendant's Archivist office bears only on the S4 disqualification consequence, which does not arise absent a violation. The defense's appeals to necessity, drought, and inherited lessons are not elements or exceptions of S3 and are not relied upon; the finding rests solely on the recorded intensity. Consequences are for the engine.
Matter is not case
matter_0369ecbc0c… deduplicated legal question
case_00ec163e6a… adjudication record
precedent_8b046fb8b0… later-available holding
These IDs resolve into one dossier for navigation while retaining their distinct meanings.